Dedicated to my late brave, beautiful and silly mummy, Debra Ross. I love you mumster.

Skip navigation

Google Reader feature requests

So I’ve been using Google Reader again for a week or so now and am enjoying it much more this time around. While virtually nothing has changed from when I used it constantly last year (when I got a response from a Google employee on this post in October 2006), now I’m following and sharing material with some extrodinarily interesting people from around the world, and am learning a lot.

This isn’t to say Google Reader is perfect; in fact if it came down to just the user interfaces I’d still say IAC’s Bloglines has it beat. Comparisons aside, here’s a laundry list of features I’d like to see:

Auto posting of comments
If someone posts a note about one of your posts in their shared items, it’d be nice if Google reader could leave a trackback link on your blog or even post the comment itself on your blog. I understand if such a system would have to be opt-in, and I understand people should have the ability to block their notes from being sent too if they want to remain private. I just feel as though I might be missing out on some good discussion here by people who don’t use Google Reader.
Easier friend adding
It seems a bit counter intuitive and convoluted that I needed to have communicated with someone using their Gmail account before a person gets added to my Google Reader "friends" section. If someone is using Google Reader, they MUST have a Google account… so why can’t I, a fellow Google account holder, just press a "Request Friendship" button on their shared items page? Why must it go through Gmail at all?
A non-Ajax version
I really dislike using pages with lots of Ajax. I don’t agree with the currently held idea that Ajax makes pages more accessible and easier to use… I know I’m in the minority though. Still, couldn’t we have a regular HTML version that works as you would expect?
Less iPhone crashing
The iPhone version of Google Reader is very slick and easy to use, which makes it great for reading feeds even when I’m on the train! What’s irritating though is it’s one of the few web pages that consistently crashes my iPhone and I don’t know why. It’s probably got something to do with downloading too many elements at the same time.
A dark background with light text
A simple little toggle button, for those of us who read our Google Reader feeds first thing in the morning and who’s eyes aren’t ready for the onslaught of "blazing white"?
A Google Reader… Reader
It’d be nice if you could click a button to get a cute person to read your posts for you :)
Battery charging ability, coffee generation
Whether I’m using Google Reader on my mammoth MacBook Pro, my tiny retro but better-than-a-netbook Armada M300 or my iPhone, I should be able to have it charge my device while I use it. And if browsing on a desktop, the extra energy should feed back into the power grid to supplement my bills. As an extra perk (ha!) it’d be great if it could brew coffee too.
Ability to filter huge animated GIFs
It surprises me how many people include huge (filesize and dimensions) animated GIFs in their feeds. It’d be nice to turn them off without turning all images off.
Automatic blog publishing
If you browse my del.icio.us category, you can see all the posts that del.icio.us generated for me automatically each day with the links I saved back in 2006. I stopped using it because having a post with just a bunch of links didn’t seem that useful. If Google Reader though could automagically create a blog post with links to each article you’ve commented on along with said comments each day, that’d be fantastic.
SMS or Twitter alerts
It’d be great if I could tell Google Reader to send me a text message or a Twitter tweet every time a particular phrase or keyword is mentioned. I’d love to be one of the first to see a post about what a moron "Ruben Schade" is.
People recommendations
Google Reader already suggests blogs you may be interested in, why not extend this to people’s shared items you may be interested in?
Simple rating system
If you didn’t have time to write a comment on a shared story, it’d be great if you could just hit a "Thumbs Up!" or "Thumbs Down" button or link. I emulate this to a certain extent with some of my Google Reader tags such as "corruption", "funny" and "wish-I-was-as-cool-as-Jimbob-and-Kelli-and-Atuu-and-…"

If you have any ideas of your own, or if you’ve talked about a Google Reader wishlist on your blog, feel free to leave a comment. Grilled cheese sandwiches.

Google Reader, take three!


Now I just need to get my fabulous dad onto Google Reader…

All right everyone, I’ve finally figured out how to use Google Reader enough to use it properly. I have the little bookmarklet for my toolbar, and I’ve started following some interesting people’s shared items. I’ve also started sharing items of my own, and commenting on each. You can follow my shared items at:

http://www.google.com/reader/shared/09454950261221562208

If it makes it easier, my original redirect link also works too:

http://rubenerd.com/googlereader/

And here’s the Atom XML feed to subscribe to directly to.

Now the only question I still have is how Todd (a fellow Whole Wheat Radio listener) for example sometimes has his own name next to comments, but sometimes the name of someone else too. Do you need to be “friends” with the person to do that? Is it possible to comment live on someone else’s shared items… is that what that is?

ASIDE: I miss hanging out with my dad in Singapore… because he’s not "just" my dad, he’s my best friend.

I must say once you get the hang of it, Google Reader is wildly useful: I’ve even posted a page about the Moleskine notebook I bought this afternoon online! The learning curve though is huge: I haven’t had this much trouble learning how to use a web app (or a regular app for that matter) in a long time. I may even harbour a tiny bit of longing and nostalgia for trusty Bloglines which I dearly loved years ago. I guess it’s all about getting used to something new.

Now I just need the links for Attu and Sparks and I think I’ll be in business. :-D

Camino and Google Reader atom problems

Sharon777 on Twitter pointed out a possible problem with either the Camino browser or Google Reader. If you use Camino to browse someone’s Google Reader Shared Items page (such as mine or Whole Wheat Radio’s), an web feed notification icon doesn’t appear in the address bar:

Google Reader in Camino not showing a web feed icon

However if you click View Page Source in the View menu, you can clearly see the link to the web feed:

Google Reader in Camino not showing a web feed icon

I can’t really think why it shouldn’t find it. Perhaps Camino has trouble with Atom feeds as opposed to RSS. When I have some more time I’ll see if I can reproduce the error somehow.

Google Reader shared items

I’m in the process of writing up a post on my university intranet blog about how I’m addicted to information and some of the tools I use to help me with it, but I figured this particular feature on this particular service was worthy of its own post. Brace yourself: I’ve finally made the switch from Bloglines to Google Reader! While I still think Bloglines has a marginally better interface, and the Bloglines Beta looks promising, I’m really sold on Google Reader’s Shared Items system.

Shared Items allows you to show people exactly what you’re reading. If you’re reading a particular blog entry, news story or Chuck Norris joke in Google Reader and find it interesting, you can click the Share link in the post’s footer and it magically appears on your Shared Items page which you can give people the link for. It’s really very long and ugly, so I created a symlink to make it easier (especially for me!) to remember:

http://rubenerd.com/googlereader/

One particularly important feature they added recently was the ability to change the style of your Shared Items page. Mine now includes a cute fish tank in the header, very useful.